Choosing Between Calcutta University and Presidency University for an Economics PG Course
When it comes to pursuing a postgraduate (PG) course in economics, two prominent universities in Kolkata often come up in discussions: Calcutta University (CU) and Presidency University. Both have their unique strengths and can provide different experiences for students. This article aims to help prospective students make an informed decision based on their goals and preferences.
Corporate Placements and Beyond
For students looking to secure a corporate placement, Madras School of Economics (MSE) within Calcutta University is generally considered the better option. Barring a few exceptions with Presidency University, the job market recognizes and values MSE more highly. With over 200 seats in the five courses offered, MSE provides a wider pool of opportunities for placements, which is crucial in the current economic climate. However, if students aspire to a career abroad or want to study in a younger, more dynamic environment, Presidency University might be the ideal choice.
Academic Legacy and Recognition
Presidency University Kolkata is a venerable institution with over 200 years of rich heritage. It has earned numerous accolades, including an A grade with a score of 3.04/4.00 from the University Grants Commission (UGC) and affiliations from both NAAC and AIU. This recognition emphasizes its standing in the academic community. Moreover, its history as a center for excellence, with two Nobel Laureates, contributes to its strong reputation. This legacy also means that students may have the chance to interact with visiting faculty members, enhancing their learning experiences.
Placement Opportunities and Exposure
From the perspective of placements, MSE at Calcutta University has a significant edge. With over 200 seats available in its economics courses, MSE offers more opportunities for students to find suitable placements. This is particularly advantageous in the current uncertain market conditions where job placements can be unpredictable. In contrast, Presidency University, while still reputable, has a limited number of seats, which can restrict placement opportunities.
In terms of exposure and the overall campus experience, MSE provides a broader platform. The course is designed to be more refined, attracting a diverse student body from across India. This diversity in terms of demographics, backgrounds, and perspectives can enrich the learning experience and encourage more active participation in both academic and extracurricular activities. For students who are proactive and enjoy being part of such vibrant communities, MSE might be the better fit.
Personal Experience and Teaching Quality
Calcutta University is often associated with less favorable academic environments, where students may receive lower grades due to the involvement of teachers who are also part of the question-setting board. The process of grading is often opaque, leading to uncertainty in securing good marks. On the other hand, Presidency University offers a more transparent and familiar teaching environment. Teachers are typically more approachable, and students can expect to receive more personalized attention during exams, increasing the chances of achieving better grades.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the choice between Calcutta University and Presidency University for a PG course in economics depends on individual preferences and goals. MSE at Calcutta University is better for corporate placements and exposure, while Presidency University offers a more structured and traditional academic environment. While I cannot dictate which option is better, it's advisable to consider the unique advantages and drawbacks of each institution to make an informed decision.