Choosing Between Writing a Picture Book and a Coloring Book for Older Children
Choosing between writing a picture book and a coloring book for older children is an important decision for any author, especially when the content involves teaching with both words and pictures. The decision often lies in the hands of the publisher or the would-be publisher, who will assign a specific genre to your work. However, there are several factors to consider, including market trends, financial aspects, and the overall impact on your intended audience.
Market Trends and Sales
When considering the market, it is important to note that picture books generally have a higher sales volume compared to coloring books. Libraries are more likely to accession picture books due to their educational and entertaining value, whereas coloring books are less frequently acquired. This trend suggests that picture books offer a more reliable audience base and a greater potential for long-term engagement.
Economic Considerations
The economic aspect is another crucial factor to consider. Picture books can offer higher royalty rates, especially when publishers feel that they are investing in a high-quality, educational, or entertaining product. The cover price of coloring books is often lower, and this can impact the profitability for both the publisher and the author. Additionally, coloring books may require royalties to be shared with the copyright owners of any characters included in the book. This is particularly evident in books tied to popular culture figures, which can come with additional costs and complex legal issues.
Generic vs. Non-Generic Content
Generic coloring books, which are not tied to specific characters or franchises, often struggle to compete with books that have a narrative or story element. Picture books, on the other hand, can incorporate a variety of content, from teaching moral lessons to immersing children in unique and creative stories. For example, a simple picture of a balloon may not require exclusive rights, as motion picture studios do not own the rights to such common objects and scenes.
Creating a Children’s Book
Given the choices between picture books and coloring books, it might be beneficial to consider writing and illustrating a children’s book that incorporates both text and illustrations. This approach can offer a more engaging and comprehensive learning experience for older children. By combining storytelling and visual elements, you can create a richer, more interactive experience that not only entertains but also educates. Libraries and parents are often more inclined to choose books that include both words and illustrations, as they provide a well-rounded educational value.
Conclusion
In summary, when deciding between writing a picture book and a coloring book for older children, consider the market trends, economic factors, and the overall impact on your intended audience. Choosing a children’s book that includes both text and illustrations can offer a more engaging and comprehensive learning experience, potentially leading to higher sales and better financial returns for the author. By creating a well-rounded book that captures the imagination and curiosity of older children, you can ensure a successful and lasting impact.