Citing Dissertations in Research Papers: Guidelines and Considerations

Citing a dissertation in a research paper can be a valuable practice, provided certain guidelines and considerations are followed. Understanding when it is acceptable, how to cite it, and whether to prioritize it over peer-reviewed literature is crucial for maintaining the integrity and credibility of your research. This article aims to provide clarity on these matters.

Is it Acceptable to Cite a Dissertations?

Indeed, citing a dissertation is acceptable as long as it is properly cited and meets the necessary criteria. Dissertations are valuable resources for research, especially those completed recently. They offer deep insights into a particular subject and can be a wealth of information, particularly if the candidate is a well-published or renowned expert in the field.

Quality and Credibility of Dissertations

Despite their value, dissertations are still considered "student work" and may not carry the same level of credibility as peer-reviewed scholarly articles or books. This is because the review process for dissertations is not as rigorous as that for peer-reviewed literature. Typically, dissertations undergo scrutiny from a committee of 5-6 professors and a public defense. However, this does not guarantee the same level of peer review as scholarly journals. Therefore, it is advisable to review the references cited in the dissertation and consider other scholarly publications that may be more appropriate for your research.

Published Results of a Dissertation

When citing a dissertation, it is often beneficial to check if the author has published the results in a peer-reviewed journal. Publication in a journal typically indicates a higher level of academic scrutiny and validation. If the author has published the results, it is preferable to cite the peer-reviewed article rather than the dissertation itself, as the journal publication has undergone a more rigorous review process.

Acceptance by a Regionally Accredited University

A dissertation accepted by a regionally accredited university is a form of scholarly work. Dissertations undergo a refereed process similar to the publication of journal articles. The dissertation must pass the scrutiny of a committee and a public defense. However, the process is not identical to peer review. Therefore, while a dissertation is a valuable resource, it is generally recommended to seek peer-reviewed literature to enhance the credibility of your research.

Thoughts on the Scholarly Work Presented in a Dissertation

Often, the references cited in a dissertation are as useful or even more so than the dissertation itself. If your information originates from a dissertation, it is important to explore the references provided. Published articles based on the research presented in the dissertation may offer more relevant and current information. Additionally, the thinking on the scholarly work presented in the dissertation is often refined and presented to the academic community through published articles, making them a valuable source for your research.

Citation Guidelines

When citing a dissertation, ensure you follow the appropriate citation format according to your academic discipline. If the dissertation has not been published, you should indicate this in your citation to maintain transparency. Familiarize yourself with the specific citation style your academic institution or journal requires. This will help ensure your research is presented in a professional and credible manner.

Conclusion

While it is acceptable to cite a dissertation in a research paper, it is important to weigh its credibility carefully. Prioritizing peer-reviewed literature when available is generally advised to enhance the academic rigor of your research. By properly citing and considering the resources in a dissertation, you can leverage its valuable insights while maintaining the integrity of your work.

Key Takeaways:

Citing dissertations is acceptable but not recommended over peer-reviewed sources. Dissertations must pass a rigorous review process but lack the same level of peer review as scholarly journals. References within a dissertation are often as valuable as the dissertation itself. Check for published articles that stem from the dissertation for more current and refined information. Proper citation format is crucial to maintain academic credibility.

For further guidance on research and citation practices, consult your academic institution's style guide or seek advice from your instructors and academic advisors.