Could Sherlock Holmes Crack IIT?

Imagine if Sherlock Holmes, the brilliant and eccentric detective from Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s stories, decided to take the Indian Institutes of Technology (IIT) Joint Entrance Examination (JEE). Despite his incomparable skills in deduction, chemistry, and problem-solving, would he have the temperament to crack such a rigorous and demanding exam?

Sherlock Holmes’ Problem-solving Abilities

In the stories, we see that Holmes is a master of problem-solving, stating, “Give me problems, give me work, give me the most abstruse cryptogram, the most intricate analysis, and I am in my proper atmosphere” (A Scandal in Bohemia). His analytical skills and memory are legendary. Let's explore how these traits might translate to the IITJEE exam.

Chemistry

As an avid chemist, Holmes would undoubtedly excel in chemistry. With his eidetic memory and astounding analytical skills, he would easily grasp complex chemical concepts and memorize vast amounts of information. The JEE Chemistry section, which tests knowledge of organic, inorganic, and physical chemistry, would be well within his grasp. He might even find such problems stimulating rather than tedious.

Mathematics

For mathematics, Holmes’ exceptional visualization skills would prove invaluable. He could "see" problems and solutions in his mind, making rough paper redundant. He might even enjoy the challenge of advanced math problems, but simpler calculations involving formulas might be less appealing.

Physics

Holmes would likely excel in out-of-the-box physics problems, particularly those requiring creative thinking and unconventional approaches. However, routine calculations and standard formulas might feel like a mundane challenge for such a brilliant mind, as he often transcends conventional methods. Still, with his innate problem-solving skills, he would likely manage to solve even the most complex physics problems.

The Dilemma

Despite his extraordinary abilities, the routine and boredom of the IITJEE exam might present a significant challenge. Holmes is known to abhor dull routine, and the exam would represent a stark contrast to his deductive and analytical prowess. He might struggle with the repetitive nature of the exam, which requires extensive practice and preparation.

Moreover, the practical aspect of the exam, where one must actually write out the answers, might not align with Holmes’ methods. He is known for his disdain for relying on artificial stimulants, preferring to rely on his own intelligence and skills. Writing lengthy answers and solving problems by circling options would go against his preferred method of problem-solving.

Furthermore, fame and recognition are things Holmes finds contradictory to his nature. While he aspires to solve the most complex problems, the public recognition that comes with the IITJEE might not sit well with him. He might prefer to observe the exam hall and derive his own conclusions rather than participating in the exam.

Conclusion

While Sherlock Holmes’ exceptional analytical and problem-solving skills suggest he could crack the IITJEE if he were to put his mind to it, his personality and preferred methods might hinder his performance. The dull routine and mundane calculations of the exam could prove to be a significant challenge for the brilliant detective.

Whether or not Holmes would even choose to take the exam is a question of his own intellectual and personal pursuits. Regardless, his problem-solving skills and innate curiosity would make him a formidable candidate for the IITJEE, even if the exam itself might not be to his preference.

Keywords: Sherlock Holmes, IITJEE, Problem Solving