Do Main Characters Need to Be Likable?

When it comes to character development in storytelling, one of the most commonly debated topics is whether the main character needs to be likable. The answer is a resounding no. As long as the character is interesting and compelling, and resonates with the audience in a relatable manner, likability can often take a backseat.

Non-Likable Yet Compelling Characters

Characters that aren't likable can still be compelling and engaging. This is illustrated by well-known examples that defy traditional notions of what a likeable character should be:

Sherlock Holmes: Often portrayed as rude and antisocial, Holmes remains one of the most captivating characters in literature. His exceptional intelligence, deductive reasoning, and unique personality traits make him a central figure in crime-solving stories. James Bond: Known for his arrogance and sharp wit, Bond has been an iconic character since the 1950s. His relatable traits of intelligence, charisma, and a willingness to take risks make him a favorite among fans, even when his methods may not be entirely likable. Dracula: With his vampiric nature and mysterious allure, Dracula remains a thrilling character that captivates audiences. His supernatural powers and complex personality keep readers and viewers engrossed, despite his inherently unlikable nature. Dexter Morgan: The protagonist of the hit series “Dexter,” Dexter is a killer. However, his ethical justifications and emotional complexity make him a compelling, if not likable, character. Dexter's world and his moral turmoils provide a unique perspective on mantle of power and justice. Frankenstein's Monster: Frankenstein's creation is tragic but not necessarily likable, yet he remains a figure of fascination. His interesting storyline and emotional journey make him a compelling character in literary works. Mr. Darcy: In Jane Austen’s “Pride and Prejudice,” Mr. Darcy starts off as an unlikable character, but as the story progresses, he develops into a more sympathetic and relatable individual. His transformation adds depth to his character and to the narrative.

Characters You Love to Hate

Sometimes, the characters that we love to hate can be the most engaging. Examples include:

Sheldon Cooper: From "The Big Bang Theory," Sheldon is portrayed as rude, arrogant, and socially awkward, yet his quirks and intelligence make him a significant character. Jim Parsons' performance is compelling and has earned him numerous accolades. He is a complex character that resonates with viewers in a relatable but unlikeable manner.

Leroy Jethro Gibbs: While Leroy Jethro Gibbs from "NCIS" may not be the most likable character in the show, he commands respect from his team. His tormented past and strict adherence to his principles make him a character of great depth, though his aloofness and emotional barriers can make him less relatable to some viewers.

Jac Naylor: From "Holby City," Jac is a character known for her sharp tongue and mysterious personality. Her background of growing up in care and witness to sexual abuse adds layers to her character, making her a intriguing and relatable figure despite being considered unlikable.

Manny Kaan: From "House of Lies," Manny is a character that may not be ideal for everyone. Don Cheadle's portrayal of this unethical and often underhanded character makes the series both entertaining and controversial. While he represents relatability in his predatory behavior and moral grey areas, he is far from likable, which adds to the show's intrigue.

The Importance of Relatability Over Likability

While likability can enhance the quality of the experience, it is not always necessary. The ability to relate to a character's traits, background, or motivations can make a character more engaging:

Otto in 'A Fish Called Wanda': Otto is a character that embodies reprehensible qualities, yet he is one of the funniest and most memorable in the film. His selfish and rude nature serve to highlight the disparity between American and British culture, turning him into a relatable figure even when his actions are unlikable.

Iron Man: Tony Stark, also known as Iron Man, is often seen as brash, irresponsible, and uncooperative. While these qualities may initially turn some viewers off, his complex personality and evolution over the years make him a compelling character. His flaws are part of what makes him human and relatable.

Conclusion: In summary, while likability can enhance the appeal of characters, it is not a prerequisite for a compelling role. Instead, characters should focus on being interesting, complex, and relatable, even if they are not always likeable. Viewers and players are drawn to stories where the characters feel authentic and genuine, even if their actions are questionable.