Engineering vs Teaching: Are There Reasons for Engineers Not to Pursue a Career in Education?

Engineering vs Teaching: Are There Reasons for Engineers Not to Pursue a Career in Education?

When considering a career in education, especially as a teacher or adjunct faculty member, engineers often weigh the pros and cons, often finding the decision challenging. This article explores some reasons why an engineer might not want to become a teacher, highlighting the differences between the career paths and providing insights from firsthand experiences.

The Role and Responsibilities of an Educator

Let’s define what it means to be a teacher. For example, I have taught basic electronics as adjunct faculty at a local private college for several years in the 1990s. It was a great part-time job that allowed me to sharpen my knowledge and skills. However, teaching at the high school or lower grade levels can be entirely different, requiring a different set of skills and expectations.

Teaching at the high school or lower grade levels involves understanding the needs of students who are often adult learners or younger individuals. These students come from varied backgrounds, some of whom may lack interest in the topics being taught. As an engineer, you are likely to be part of a classroom environment where you are smarter than most of your peers, but dealing with policies, work rules, and classroom management can be frustrating.

Challenges Faced by Engineers in Education

First, starting at the bottom can be daunting. Regardless of your engineering experience, you have no teaching experience. Second, pay can be a shock. In larger metro areas, teacher pay might be comparable to that of other government employees, but it's usually not at the higher end of the salary spectrum. It can be comparable to the entry-level pay for a 22-year-old engineer.

Third, you may find yourself smarter than most of your peers. However, the policies and work rules in education can drive you crazy. Additionally, dealing with students who lack interest and have more pressing concerns like attending parties and impressing the opposite sex can be challenging. These are experiences that younger students in the classroom may prioritize over learning.

Lastly, you may face significant discipline issues and a lack of support from administration and parents. Teachers' unions are often vilified, and while their protections can vary, the lack of support for quality of work can be a reality. Engineering graduates, particularly, may find the current trend of “woke” politics in some urban areas to be overwhelming, especially in STEM courses.

Why Some Engineers Might Be a Poor Fit for Teaching

The personality types that thrive in teaching do not always align with the characteristics of successful engineers. Being an engineer often requires analytical problem-solving skills, attention to detail, and a desire to create innovative solutions. However, teaching requires patience, adaptability, and an ability to connect with students on a personal level. Engineers may struggle with the broader social responsibilities that teaching entails, such as being a part-time social worker to address the needs of students in a classroom setting.

That being said, some degreed engineers might find that they have missed their calling. If you have the temperament and passion for teaching, it could be the right decision for you. However, it's important to go into the role with your eyes wide open, understanding the challenges and rewards involved.

Sources and Further Reading

For more insights, consider reading the following articles:

Why Do People Hate Teachers Unions? - Ted Cordes What Are Some of the Biggest Problems with Public Education in America? - Ted Cordes Why Aren't There More People Who Want to Become Teachers? - Matthew Bates What Is an Example of a Misconception in Education? - Matthew Bates

Remember, if you choose to pursue a career in teaching, some schools can provide a rewarding environment, but the wrong location can make it a living hell. The right preparation and mindset are crucial to navigating the challenges and finding success in this field.