Is AP Spanish Worth It for Non-Native Speakers?

As a non-native speaker who took 3 years of Spanish at your high school and received an A, should you take AP Spanish? This decision depends on several factors, including your comprehension and writing skills, the rigor of the course, and the long-term benefits versus the short-term costs.

Assessing Your Readiness

Your Spanish comprehension and writing skills must be excellent to excel in AP Spanish. Even native speakers may struggle if they don’t study regularly. The course content is amazing, but the rigor of AP Spanish is high. Teachers can provide invaluable insights into whether you are prepared for the depth and pace of the class. They can also help you determine if you have sufficient time to master the material and achieve a grade that will be impressive in class and on the exam.

Benefits for College Applicants

If your college requires a foreign language, most majors in the College of Arts and Sciences require one. AP Spanish can provide significant benefits, especially for those planning to earn college credits. One state flagship institution offers a full 12 credit hour credit for a 5 on the AP Spanish Language and Culture exam. Carefully compare the long-term benefits of AP Spanish against the short-term costs of taking the course.

Why Spanish Taught in Class Seems Wasteful

Learning Spanish in the classroom can be seen as a waste of time, particularly for those who live in areas without frequent Spanish-speaking populations. Even in areas with Spanish-speaking residents, engaging in conversation can be challenging. Natives may struggle with certain aspects, and non-native speakers may face additional difficulties.

The Challenges of Speaking Spanish

While you might live in a place like Minot ND and have access to the internet and Spanish TV channels, actual conversations can be difficult. Even in Mexico, slang and regional variations can make it challenging to communicate effectively. Words that carry different meanings in different countries can lead to misunderstandings.

Choosing Elective Courses

Elective courses are an important part of your senior year. Besides Spanish, here are some worthy options:

Philosophy or Psychology: These can be valuable for understanding critical thinking and mental health. Drafting: While not as common, drafting skills might be useful if you're considering a career in engineering. Elective Science and Literature Classes: These can be beneficial in expanding your knowledge and interests.

Considering the Importance of STEM Courses

Some high schools offer more than just foreign language courses. Consider taking AP science courses such as Biology, Chemistry, Physics, or Statistics. AP courses can provide substantial knowledge and help you understand if you have an interest in STEM fields. It's important to note that while most high schools cannot fully prepare you for top-tier colleges, taking challenging courses like AP science can help you stand out.

Common Misconceptions About AP Classes

Some perceive AP classes as challenging, and rightly so. However, some students might opt for AP Spanish over other AP classes, believing it’s more manageable. It's crucial to understand that while AP Spanish is rigorous, AP science courses like Calculus and Physics can also be demanding.

Real-World Examples

There are success stories of students who struggled in high school AP classes and were pushed out of prestigious universities. However, like the top astrophysicist Moriba Jah, perseverance and a strong desire for knowledge can lead to significant achievements. His work in outer space and space policing highlights the importance of long-term dedication to learning.

Ultimately, the choice to take AP Spanish should be based on your goals, interests, and time management. Consulting your teacher for advice and assessing the long-term benefits versus short-term costs can help guide your decision.