Why did Modi Buy an 800 Cr Aeroplane?

The allegations of wasteful government spending often revolve around Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s recent purchase of two VVIP (Very Important Person) aircraft, costing approximately 800 crore rupees (approximately $110 million USD). The criticisms from opposition parties, particularly Congress leader Rahul Gandhi, paint a picture of a wasteful government, but a closer look reveals a more nuanced story.

Background of the Procurement Process

The process for procuring these VVIP aircraft has a complex history. The procurement began in 2011 during the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government under Manmohan Singh. An Inter-Ministerial Group (IMD) reviewed various options and submitted its recommendations in 2012 after 10 meetings. The contracts were then placed by the UPA government.

It is important to note that while the procurement began under the UPA, the current government has ensured the process reaches a conclusion. The aircraft have already been delivered to India, signifying the end of a long and often politically contentious journey.

Allegations vs. Reality

Opposition voices, including Rahul Gandhi, have criticized the procurement and likened it to wasteful spending. However, these criticisms are often hypocritical, given that past administrations have faced similar accusations without due regard for historical context. For instance, Congress party leaders forget that the Atal Tunnel, often touted as their achievement, was conceptualized and inaugurated by former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee in 2002. Their current claims of credit are based more on political expediency than genuine achievements.

Modi’s Motivation for Procurement

A key question is whether this procurement was indeed necessary. While one can argue both sides, here are some key points to consider:

Purpose of the Aircraft

National Security and Diplomatic Needs: VVIP aircraft serve as a symbol of national prestige and are vital for diplomatic engagements. The need for two such aircraft can be justified if they ensure safe transport for key officials such as the Prime Minister during emergencies or high-profile visits. Fleet Management: If one aircraft fails or is not sufficient, backup is critical. Two aircraft can provide redundancy, ensuring reliable and uninterrupted operations. Future Requirements: There is no certainty that the current aircraft will meet future requirements. Updating technology and ensuring safety protocols are always evolving.

Elephant in the Room: the Upcoming Election

Another consideration is the upcoming 2024 general election. While it’s tempting to argue that spending on such luxury items is inappropriate, it must be understood that political leaders have a duty to ensure national security and readiness for contingencies. The argument that the aircraft will not be used by the current Prime Minister in the next term is flawed because the planes are intended for the role of Prime Minister, not any individual. It is a state asset rather than a personal one.

Comprehending the Context of Government Spending

It’s also crucial to understand the harsh economic reality of India. Challenges such as high unemployment, increasing farmer suicides, and rising instances of violence (such as gang rapes) paint a grim picture. In times of crisis, governments often need to make difficult decisions, and procuring vital equipment for national security and diplomatic needs can be seen as a necessary investment in the future.

Conclusion

While the procurement of VVIP aircraft might seem extravagant in the context of a country facing many socio-economic challenges, a more balanced view is necessary. The procurement began under the UPA government and aligns with a need for modernizing India’s transportation capabilities. The current government has ensured the process is completed, ensuring national security and diplomatic readiness.

Tags: #Modi #VVIP Aircraft #Government Procurement