Navigating Modern English Grammar: Beyond Wren and Martin’s Traditional Approach

When it comes to high school English grammar, High School English Grammar and Composition by P.C. Wren and H. Martin is a well-known text. However, understanding how to best learn from it and whether it's suited for modern learners requires a critical evaluation. This article aims to guide you through the options available in the realm of English grammar education, focusing on the limitations and strengths of these traditional resources.

Why Learn English Grammar?

Before diving into the nitty-gritty, it's important to clarify your goals. Are you looking to learn old-fashioned grammar, improve your spoken English, or pass a state exam? Understanding your objective will help determine the right resource for you.

The Wren and Martin Approach: An Historical View

High School English Grammar and Composition by P.C. Wren and H. Martin, first published in 1935, is a classic choice for many. But, as Wikipedia notes, the content originates from The Manual of English Grammar and Composition by J.C. Nesfield, which was published in 1908. This historical context is crucial for modern learners.

Historical Context and Limitations:
- Published in 1935: Language evolves rapidly over 85 years; this book won't provide the most up-to-date grammar rules.
- Target Audience: Primarily for British children living in Colonial India. It assumes a prior knowledge of English and is aimed at schoolchildren.
- Grammar Focus: Contains a lot of old-fashioned and traditional grammar rules rather than contemporary English grammar practices.

Modern Alternatives for English Grammar Learning

If your goal is to learn modern English grammar, there are better alternatives available. Here are some recommended resources:

Headway: A series of student books designed for English language learners, focusing on all four skills (speaking, listening, reading, and writing) and offering comprehensive grammar practice. cutting edge: Designed to help learners improve their English in a variety of contexts, this series includes engaging activities that promote both fluency and accuracy. State Exam Prep Books: If your aim is to pass a state exam, the best approach is to study and practice past exam papers, which will give you a clear sense of the material and format you need to master.

Learning Old-Fashioned Grammar

If your goal is specifically to learn grammar from a 1935-era textbook, reading Wren and Martin could be a valuable exercise. However, it's not ideal for those seeking contemporary English grammar. Here's how you can approach it:

Read for Fun: Approach the book with an interest in historical language practices. It can be an educational and interesting read, but it won't provide modern-day English grammar rules.

Supplement with Modern Resources: Use it as a supplementary text to better understand the older language practices. Pair it with contemporary grammar guides for a well-rounded education.

Consolidate with Current Standards: Ensure you also study current grammar texts or online resources to see the differences between past and present grammatical norms.

Conclusion

Your choice of grammar resource should align with your learning goals. For modern learners, it's essential to focus on up-to-date grammatical rules and practices. If you're interested in the history of English grammar, Wren and Martin can provide a valuable historical perspective. However, it should be used in conjunction with current resources for a comprehensive understanding of the English language.

Remember, the key to effective learning is a balanced and focused approach that aligns with your goals and the evolution of the English language.