Should Medical Advice Be Sought on Quora When Experts Are Unvetted?
Doctors and lawyers both share a common ethical principle - they cannot ethically provide advice without a formal relationship established between them and their clients. Whether it be a patient-doctor relationship or an attorney-client relationship, the foundational trust and direct communication between these professionals are necessary for providing reliable and legally compliant advice. This principle likely extends to the allied health professions as well.
However, the online platform Quora, despite its vast amount of aggregated knowledge, does not meet these stringent ethical requirements for providing medical advice. Quora, as a public forum, does not vet its contributors, which means that anyone can post answers or information, even if they are not healthcare professionals. When it comes to matters of health and safety, this lack of vetting can be particularly problematic.
Establishing Credibility on Quora
Quora, understanding the need for proper credibility, provides a disclaimer to its users. This disclaimer typically appears when discussing legal topics, but it is notably absent in discussions related to medical advice. Such a disclaimer reminds users that the information they receive on Quora is just that - information. Users must take the initiative to verify the credentials of those answering their questions to ensure the reliability of the advice.
Common Responses on Quora
When it comes to medical questions, the responses are often limited and generally advisory. Users are often directed to seek professional medical help, rather than receiving direct medical advice. Phrases like "it could be this or that" or "please go to a doctor immediately if you have concerns" are common. Even when doctors do answer, they tend to offer general advice, which may not be sufficient for specific medical inquiries.
Consequences of Unvetted Advice
The unvetted nature of information on Quora can lead to the spread of misinformation, delayed diagnosis, and potentially harmful health practices. While the platform encourages user experience and collective wisdom, it cannot replace the importance of professional medical advice. Medical practitioners are trained and licensed to diagnose conditions and provide tailored treatment plans. Ignoring this professional advice can have severe health consequences.
Alternative Sources of Medical Advice
For those seeking reliable medical advice, alternative sources should be considered. Visiting a healthcare provider, consulting with a medical professional through a telemedicine service, or checking reputable health websites can all offer a more accurate and professional response to health concerns. These sources provide the necessary level of expertise and ethics to ensure that the advice given is both safe and effective.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while Quora can be a valuable resource for health-related information, it should not be the sole or primary source for seeking medical advice. The lack of vetting of expert contributors, coupled with the often general and advisory nature of the responses, makes it unsuitable for obtaining specific, reliable medical advice. Users should always seek professional medical help, especially when dealing with health concerns.