Should We Be Feminists or Humanists?

There is an ongoing debate about whether one must be a humanist or a feminist in order to truly advocate for the greater good. This article aims to explore the nuances of both ideologies and determine why embracing both perspectives collectively is not only beneficial but essential.

What Is Humanism?

Humanism is a broad term that encompasses a philosophical and ethical stance that emphasizes the value and agency of human beings individually and collectively. It generally values critical thinking, evidence, and reason, rejecting dogma and superstition. Humanists believe in improving the human condition through education, rationality, and ethical living.

What Is Feminism?

Feminism is the advocacy of women's rights on the basis of the equality of the sexes. It aims to address the systemic inequalities faced by women in various aspects of society, such as politics, economics, and social structures. Feminists seek to challenge and change these inequalities through various means, including activism, legal reforms, and cultural shifts.

Why Not Just Humanism?

The attempt to frame discussions around the concept of 'humanism' or 'egalitarianism' can often be seen as a tactic to shift attention away from specific issues affecting women. This is akin to the attempt to change the narrative from 'Black Lives Matter' to 'All Lives Matter,' which diverts focus from the real concerns faced by marginalized communities.

The Fire Analogy

Consider a scenario where a house is on fire. It would be absurd to suggest that all houses deserve equal amounts of water when one is burning. Similarly, when discussing inequality, one cannot downplay the struggles faced by women while claiming to be a proponent of equality. Just as the fire department should target resources where they are needed, feminists advocate for specific action to address the concrete issues faced by women.

Action Over Talk

It is far more effective to take concrete actions towards equality rather than merely proclaiming a belief in equal treatment. Feminists have a long history of organizing, activism, and legal work to address these issues. For example, the Civil Rights Act of 1964 in the United States, which was heavily influenced by feminist and civil rights advocates, is a clear illustration of the impact of feminist action.

The Importance of Relevant History

Ignorance of history and activism often leads to misinformed perspectives. Many critics of feminism fail to understand the depth and breadth of the movement's work, often due to a lack of awareness or education. Reading feminist literature, historical documents, and legal decisions can provide a clearer understanding of the issues and the steps taken to address them.

Conclusion

Advocating for humanism is important, but it is not a replacement for being a feminist. Feminism is a subset of humanism that focuses on the specific struggles faced by women. Both ideologies are necessary to ensure an inclusive and just society. As such, it is crucial to support and advocate for both humanism and feminism to create a more equitable world.