The Debate Over Overrated College Degrees: A Closer Look at Communications and English
The perception of which college degree is the most overrated can vary significantly based on individual circumstances and societal context. Among the frequently discussed degrees, Communications and English stand out as prime candidates for this debate.
Why Communications Might Be the Most Overrated Degree
One reason for the skepticism surrounding a Bachelor of Arts (BA) in Communications is the job market saturation. Graduates often enter a competitive field where many are vying for limited opportunities. This saturation can make it challenging to secure meaningful and specialized roles.
Furthermore, the broad focus of the Communications degree can be both a blessing and a curse. While it equips students with a diverse set of skills and knowledge, including media, public relations, and journalism, this wide range might prevent graduates from specializing effectively. This lack of specialization can hinder their ability to stand out in a crowded job market.
The perceived value of a Communications degree also comes into question. Some employers view it as less rigorous compared to degrees in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) or Business Administration. As a result, graduates may face skepticism about the practical skills and knowledge they bring to the table.
Another point of contention is the career path ambiguity. Graduates may struggle to define clear career paths, leading to uncertainty about job prospects and potential earnings.
Alternative Perspectives on Communications Degrees
Not all is lost for those with a BA in Communications. The debate is not entirely one-sided. Some argue that the skills gained in such programs, such as critical thinking, writing, and interpersonal communication, are highly valuable and transferable across many fields.
However, it’s important to recognize that the value of a degree often depends on an individual's career goals, interests, and the quality of the program at the institution they attended. A well-rounded curriculum that provides specialized training in a specific area can mitigate some of the criticisms.
The Case for a BA in English
While Communications is often discussed as an overrated degree, there are other popular choices that face similar scrutiny. For instance, a BA in English is another degree that many find overrated. This skepticism can be seen in the example of Cathy Newman's interview with Jordan Peterson. Newman, who holds a BA in English, lacked the broad academic foundation necessary to understand complex statistical and probabilistic concepts, such as the differences in probability distributions that are often discussed in psychology or economics.
For instance, Newman was unable to provide a detailed understanding of the probability distributions between men and women on various variables. This case underscores the importance of a well-rounded education when it comes to statistical analysis and professional practice.
The Myth of Glamorized Degrees
Ultimately, the idea that a degree somehow guarantees a general or even superior knowledge of the subject matter is a myth. The quality of an education often lies in the hands of the individual and the institution they choose. While a degree can serve as a milestone, it does not automatically translate to in-depth expertise or extensive knowledge.
This perspective extends to other popular degrees as well. Degrees like Business Administration and Psychology are also often discussed as overrated due to their popularity and the competitive job market. However, like Communications, the value of these degrees can vary greatly depending on the specific program and the individual's career goals.
It’s crucial to approach college degrees with a critical and nuanced perspective. While these programs can provide valuable skills and knowledge, the true worth lies in the hands of the individual and the effort they put into their chosen field of study. A degree is just a piece of paper; what really matters is the knowledge and skills acquired and how they are applied in the real world.