The Divided Stage: Would You Prefer Trump or Obama at Your Graduation Ceremony?
Choosing the ideal commencement speaker for a high school graduation ceremony is no small feat. Traditionally, many prestigious institutions, including my alma mater, Notre Dame, have sought out the newly elected president to inspire their young graduates. From Barack Obama in 2009 to Donald Trump's VP Mike Pence in 2017, the choice has been clear in their own ways.
A Cautious Tradition
Would you rather have Donald Trump or Barack Obama give your high school or university graduation speech? At my alma mater, Notre Dame, the tradition values significant political figures. In 2009, Barack Obama captivated the audience, while in 2017, Mike Pence was invited and accepted. Earlier presidents, including George W. Bush, his father, Ronald Reagan, Jimmy Carter, and myself, also delivered memorable speeches in 1992, 1981, and 1977, respectively.
Why Avoid Trump?
Some argue that Donald Trump should be the commencement speaker. After all, the event could end earlier as he might not hold the audience's attention. But the reality is that Trump's commencement speech would likely be a monologue every four years, focusing on his own grievances and misfortunes. This approach would do a severe disservice to the graduates who are poised to take on the world.
Focus on the Speaker
Others suggest avoiding Trump because he would use the speech as another platform to complain about the world's treatment of him. This type of self-serving content would fail to inspire or educate the young graduates who need guidance and encouragement more than ever. A commencement speech should provide wisdom and inspiration, not a personal political rant.
Why Obama Might Be the Better Choice
Supporters of Barack Obama argue that he would deliver a more enlightening and inspiring speech. Obama's style is known for its eloquence, intelligence, humor, and focus on the students' future. A speech from Obama would be memorable not because of its incoherence but because of its meaningful content, encouraging the graduates to face the challenges ahead with confidence.
The Humor
Regardless of the choice, it's crucial to consider the impact of the speaker's presence on the overall experience. Some suggest fleeing quickly if Obama is chosen, as the humor and energy in his speech might be overwhelming. Conversely, if Trump is chosen, one can imagine the after-party starting sooner due to the anticipated quick departure.
Conclusion
In this divided era, the choice between Trump and Obama as a commencement speaker for high school or university graduates boils down to which figure can best inspire and empower the next generation. Obama, with his visionary words and practical guidance, would undoubtedly be the better choice for any aspiring leader. The graduates need a role model who can inspire them to face the future with courage and resilience.