The Meaning and Application of 'The Inclination Only Desires That Which is Forbidden' in Judaism
Understanding the complexities of Jewish Law, particularly within Agadic Statements and vows in Judaism, is essential for interpreting key Talmudic teachings. The statement, 'The inclination only desires that which is forbidden' (Jerusalem Talmud, Nedarim 9:1), provides profound insights that span legal and non-legal concepts, offering a comprehensive view of human nature and the covenantal relationships within Judaism.
Understanding Agadic and Legal Statements
In the Talmud, there are two primary categories of statements: legal statements, known as Halacha, and Agada, which encompass metaphysical, moral, and theological discussions. Agada is not intended to be taught literally and often contains ideas that are best understood through metaphor rather than literal interpretation. This divergence allows for the exploration of complex and multifaceted interpretations.
Interpreting the Statement 'The Inclination Only Desires That Which is Forbidden'
The statement 'The inclination only desires that which is forbidden' is embedded within the context of vows (nedarim). This thematic context is crucial for understanding its deeper meanings. According to Nedarim 9:1, this quote suggests that individuals may be drawn to things they are forbidden, due to the nature of human desires being bound by prohibitions.
This interpretation delves into the underlying reasons behind the prohibition of certain actions. For example, the prohibition placed on Adam and Eve regarding the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil was not arbitrary but deeply rooted in theological principles. This prohibition aimed to prevent them from altering human nature, which would have introduced duality and doubt, undermining the fundamental trust in the creator's wisdom.
Developments in Jewish Law and Tradition
The prohibition Adam and Eve faced set the stage for subsequent developments in Jewish law and tradition. After the original sin, the Torah was given to re-establish a covenantal relationship between God and humanity. The Jews received a set of commandments to help them navigate a world of desires and prohibitions.
The concept of covenant became central to Jewish life. Unlike vows of abstinence, these covenants were positive oaths of allegiance and loyalty to God. For instance, the act of conversion into Judaism involves a positive oath to follow the laws and teachings of God, signifying a commitment to a life of faith and obedience.
The Broader Context of Jewish Law
To fully understand the statement 'The inclination only desires that which is forbidden,' one must be familiar with the broader context of Jewish law and its development. This includes understanding where vows occur in the book of Genesis, from the time of Adam and Eve up until the giving of the Torah.
Moreover, the statement also plays a role in the covenantal relationships within Judaism, such as marriage and conversion. When a community accepts the Torah, they say 'Naseh B’Nishma,' which means 'We will do and we will listen.' This commitment means adhering to both the letter and spirit of the Torah, emphasizing trust and faith over logical analysis.
Conclusion
The statement 'The inclination only desires that which is forbidden' is multifaceted and requires a deep understanding of Jewish tradition and law. It teaches that the very limits set upon us are the very limits that challenge us. This is a powerful reminder of the importance of trust in God and the unity of purpose that binds the Jewish people together through the covenant.
For those interested in learning more about Judaism, Kabbalah, Israeli culture, and Mideast politics, please visit my Quora Space: Israel Jewish Secrets and Stuff.