The Necessity of Following Orders in the Military
Enlisted personnel in the military are expected to follow orders given by their superiors. This necessity extends from the simple and straightforward, such as performing a routine task as requested by a Corporal, to the complex and potentially life-threatening, where a direct order from a Commissioned Officer may be given. Understanding the circumstances under which orders can be disobeyed and the serious consequences of disobeying lawful orders is crucial for military personnel.
Understanding and Following Orders
Orders can vary widely in their nature, from the more ambiguous 'Private, I want you to do this' to the more direct 'Corporal, I want you to do that.' In most cases, non-commissioned officers (NCOs) are responsible for executing these orders. However, there will be scenarios where you may need to interact directly with commissioned officers daily, and the personalities and behaviors of these officers can range drastically.
Refusing an order without legal grounds can have severe consequences. It is only when orders are illegal, immoral, or likely to result in harm to yourself or others that a soldier may legitimately refuse to follow them. However, even in such cases, proof is often necessary in a court martial. Therefore, it is wise to ensure that any refusal is both justified and backed by evidence.
The Consequences of Disobeying Orders
The most common penalty for disobeying a lawful order is an Article 15, a non-judicial punishment that can include written reprimands, fines, and extra duties. Although this is a serious matter, it is necessary to follow the chain of command and respect the authority granted to superiors. Refusal of an order may eventually lead to more severe penalties, including court-martial, dishonorable discharge, or even mutiny, a grave offense that can lead to severe disciplinary actions, including the loss of rank and severe punishment.
Case Study: A Refusal That Paid Off
There have been instances where refusing an order proved beneficial. For example, an enlisted soldier took the initiative to report an Order of Duty (OOD) who was putting the ship in danger. Despite potentially facing severe consequences for doing so, the soldier's actions were correct, and the OOD faced significant punishment. This incident reinforces the importance of standing up for what is right and legal, especially when it concerns the safety and well-being of others.
While adhering to orders is an essential part of military life, it is also important to recognize that being wrong can have severe consequences. For instance, sulking or ignoring a valid order can damage a career. A simple 'Okay, sir' or 'consider it done' can mean the difference between success and failure, emphasizing the value of respect, dignity, and professionalism in these situations.
Developing Professional Maturity
Respect for authority is one of the most valuable lessons taught in the military. This respect can be instrumental in civilian life, where everyone has a boss, whether in a professional or personal context. Adhering to orders with dignity and respect can prevent personal and professional pitfalls. Inadequate respect for authority can lead to conflicts, lost opportunities, and career setbacks.
The military teaches personnel to salute and say 'Yes, sir' or 'Consider it done' with sincerity and professionalism. This skill is not only valuable in the military but can be a significant asset in the civilian world, where such demonstrations of respect and compliance can enhance one's standing and effectiveness.
Conclusion
While it is possible to refuse an order, it must be done with careful consideration and justification. Disobeying a lawful order carries serious consequences, and it is essential to follow the chain of command and respect military law. The military instills in its members the importance of respect for authority and the values of professionalism, integrity, and responsibility. These lessons are crucial for a successful and fulfilling military and civilian career.