The Subway Dilemma: Would You Rather Read or Listen?
Have you ever found yourself torn between reading a book and listening to music while on the subway? The question of whether to immerse yourself in a good book or enjoy the rhythm and beats of music is a common one for many commuters. In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of each option and share personal insights to help you make a decision that suits your unique preferences.
The Challenges of Reading on the Subway
For some, the subway can be a testing ground for their addiction to literature. However, not everyone is cut out for reading in moving vehicles. I, for one, have a well-documented issue with reading in a moving vehicle. This isn’t to say that others are incapable, but for me, the combination of movement and written words is a recipe for disaster. Whenever I try to read on a moving vehicle, I experience physical discomfort, change in skin color, and an unsettling awareness of my last meal.
My Personal Experience with Motion Sickness
My motion sickness is a condition that often strikes when I read in a moving vehicle. This isn't a universal issue, as I have observed others reading on buses and trains with ease. I attribute my sensitivity to the physiological differences in my body. The noise and movement in the subway don’t typically affect me the same way. In fact, I prefer listening to music in a quiet and calm environment, but the additional noise of the subway can be a distraction.
Living far from the nearest subway station, I often opt to walk through the city, marveling at the architecture and people around me. In densely populated areas, however, the subway remains an attractive option. When I do use the subway, I find that the right combination of music and a captivating book can be a perfect companion.
The Benefits of Listening to Music on the Subway
For those who suffer from motion sickness or find the noise of the subway to be too much of a distraction, music can be a soothing escape. In India, for instance, metros can be a bit shaky, making reading a challenge. The noise from the subway can exacerbate nausea, leading to an unpleasant experience.
Observing Commuters: A Unique Experience
One of the most interesting aspects of the subway is the opportunity it provides to observe the people around you. The diversity of faces and the stories they tell can be a source of inspiration for both readers and musicians. The people you meet and the conversations you overhear can enrich your experiences.
Making an Informed Decision
Ultimately, whether to read or listen comes down to personal preferences and circumstances. Around 1999, I made a conscious decision to listen to books on tape during my daily commute. This worked well for my situation, but if I were to move to a larger city, I would continue this practice. Listening to audiobooks has been instrumental in broadening my horizons, fostering a love for literature.
My preference for reading is bolstered by the fact that I enjoy deep, engaging genres. Books that transport me to different worlds or challenge my thinking offer a level of engagement that music alone cannot provide. However, if I were on a train reading a thriller or a comic, the rhythm of the music might be too distracting.
Conclusion
While both reading and listening to music on the subway have their merits, it’s important to choose the option that resonates most with you. Whether you prefer to immerse yourself in literature or escape into the world of music, each choice has its unique benefits and drawbacks. So, the next time you find yourself on a long subway ride, consider your options and make the decision that best suits your mood and preferences.