Understanding the January 6 Insurrectionists: Why They Refuse to Own Their Decisions and Actions

It is a well-known fact that the insurrectionists who participated in the violent attack on the United States Capitol on January 6, 2021, and their supporters who rioted and looted during the summer of 2020, often refuse to own their decisions and actions. At the core of this phenomenon lies a complex interplay of cognitive dissonance, false narratives, and a deep-seated belief in their own righteousness. This article delves into the psychological and sociological factors that contribute to this refusal.

The Role of Cognitive Dissonance

Cognitive dissonance plays a significant role in the refusal to own decisions. This psychological phenomenon occurs when an individual experiences anxiety due to holding two or more contradictory beliefs, values, or attitudes at the same time. In the case of the insurrectionists, the actions of their own supporters trashing the US Capitol Building deeply challenged their preconceived narratives and self-perceptions. It was

hard for them to reconcile the actions taken by their peers with their self-image as patriotic and law-abiding American citizens.

False Narratives and the Echo Chamber Effect

The insurrectionists often find themselves in an echo chamber where they are continually exposed to information that aligns with their pre-existing beliefs. This reinforces their view that they are acting for the greater good and that the true culprits are those opposing them. For instance, the insurrectionists often claim that

Antifa and other radical groups are to blame for the actions that took place. In their minds, it is not the insurrectionists who are at fault, but the Democrats who are trying to undermine the American way of life and the belief in traditional values.

The MAGA Narrative and Patriotic Identity

The rise of the MAGA (Make America Great Again) Patriots has fostered a strong sense of national identity and purpose among a subset of the population. Herein lies the crux of the problem: when insurrectionists act in ways that conflict with traditional notions of patriotism, the narrative shifts to blame others rather than accept responsibility. The insurrectionists often believe that only those who support MAGA are true patriots, while Democrats and other opposition groups are portrayed as enemies.

Consequences of Accepting Ownership

Accepting ownership of their actions would require insurrectionists to confront the harsh reality of their involvement in a violent and illegal act. This soul-searching process can be psychologically daunting and may lead to internal conflict. Furthermore, embracing responsibility may prompt a reassessment of their beliefs and values, potentially leading to a shift in ideology or even a loss of identity.

Conclusion

The refusal to own decisions and actions by insurrectionists is deeply rooted in cognitive dissonance and the reinforcement of false narratives. The community and media echo chambers enable these beliefs to persist, and the adoption of a narrow nationalistic identity can foster an environment where accountability is avoided. Moving forward, it is crucial to address these underlying psychological and sociological factors to promote a more nuanced and responsible understanding of American identity and the role of citizens in a democratic society.