What Happens When Two Different People Apply to Different Colleges Using the Same Common App Essay?

If you and your friend can't manage to write a university entrance essay unassisted, how do you think you'll cope with undergraduate assignments? And yes, you'll both be caught, identified as cheats, and declined a university place. University staff weren't born yesterday.

Potential Issues and Consequences

If two different applicants use the same Common App essay, several potential issues could arise:

Lack of Originality

Admissions committees are looking for unique perspectives and personal stories. If two essays are identical, it may raise concerns about the authenticity of the applicants' voices and experiences. This can cast doubt on the genuine nature of the application and potentially disqualify both candidates.

Plagiarism Concerns

Colleges expect applicants to submit their own work. Submitting an essay that is not their own is considered plagiarism, which can lead to disqualification or rejection. This is a serious matter, and institutions take academic integrity very seriously.

Impact on Admissions Chances

If one application’s essay is recognized as more compelling or well-written than the other, it could affect their chances of admission. An outstanding essay is often a critical component of a successful application, making a strong impression on admissions committees.

Institutional Policies

Different colleges may have varying policies regarding originality and academic integrity. Some institutions have strict rules against submitting identical essays, while others may focus more on the overall application. Understanding these policies is crucial before applying.

To avoid these issues, it is best for applicants to write their own essays that reflect their individual experiences, thoughts, and aspirations. Even if two applicants write on similar topics or themes, they should still strive to express their unique perspectives.

Current Scandals and Admission Policies

Probably not. The current scandal would indicate that colleges aren't too interested in rooting out cheating in the admissions process. On the other hand, why would you want to cheat if you don't have parents who can spend a half million dollars on people to write your papers for you, tutor you, and cover for you?

If you will ultimately have to do college yourself, it is better to make sure that the admissions people have a clear view of your strengths and weaknesses. They are looking to see if you'll fit, if you have a good chance of finishing the degree, and if you will pay them all the money they can get from you. If they screw up the admissions, it's money down the drain.

You want to shine yourself up, not lie. Plagiarism and cheating can lead to severe consequences, including disqualification or even academic suspension. It is better to present your true self and showcase your unique abilities and outlook.