Why Do Some People Use the Title 'Doctor'?

The term 'doctor' is a title that has evolved over centuries, carrying with it connotations of expertise, knowledge, and prestige. Historically, a doctor was someone who taught or researched, and while the term is now frequently used to denote someone with a medical degree, its original meaning remains relevant to those with doctorates in other fields, such as philosophy, law, and engineering. This article explores the nuances of title usage among professionals who have earned PhDs and other doctorates and clarifies why some individuals may choose to use the title 'doctor.'

Understanding the Title PhD

What Does PhD Stand For?

PhD, or Doctor of Philosophy, is a terminal degree in many academic fields. The title 'PhD' itself just tells us the specific discipline of the degree-holder, but in essence, it signifies a high level of knowledge and a demonstrated ability to conduct independent research. The doctorate, or doctoral degree, is the highest level of academic qualification (equivalent to Doktor in German, Dottore in Italian, and Docteur in French, among others).

TITLE USAGE IN DIFFERENT CIRCUMSTANCES

Academic Oriented Titles

Personally, I usually do not sign my name with the title 'Dr.' unless it is in an academic context. For example, I would sign my name as David L. M., , rather than Dr. David L. M. This is because the title 'Dr.' is often reserved for academics and professionals who have earned a doctorate in the medical field.

Graduation and Transition Period

My son recently completed his PhD and had a brief period before his degree was officially conferred. During this time, he could legally and appropriately refer to himself as 'Dr.' This is because the term 'doctor' predates the specialization of medicine, originally signifying a scholar or teacher regardless of the field. An M.D. (Medical Doctor) could also legally use the title 'Dr.' even before applying to medical school.

CONTEMPORARY PERCEPTIONS AND REGULATIONS

Prestige and Meaninglessness

Many non-academics view the PhD as inferior to a medical degree, asserting that PhD candidates are not 'real doctors.' However, the original meaning of the title 'doctor' relates to the principle of teaching and being a scholar. The modern medical co-opting of the title does not alter the fact that a PhD holder is indeed a 'doctor' in the more general sense, as the title indicates a high level of expertise in their field of study.

Regulatory Considerations

It is important to note that in most regions, the use of the title 'Dr.' without the appropriate academic qualifications can lead to legal and ethical issues. However, the title is a matter of self-identification and professional reputation for those who have earned it. It is a badge of honor and recognition of the significant academic achievement and research conducted.

REASONS FOR USING THE TITLE 'DR.'

Professional Identification

Using the title 'Dr.' can serve as a professional identifier, particularly in academic or research-oriented fields. It can also help to establish credibility and evoke a level of respect from peers and the general public.

Cultural and Personal Preferences

Some academic professionals may choose to use the title 'Dr.' as a matter of personal preference or cultural background. In some countries or academic circles, the use of 'Dr.' is more common and respected than in others.

---

In conclusion, the title 'doctor' is a multifaceted term with historical and contemporary meanings. While it is most commonly associated with medical professionals, the original definitions of the term align with the qualifications of a PhD holder. Therefore, those with a PhD can and do use the title 'Dr.' to reflect their academic achievements and expertise. It is a matter of professional and personal choice, but it is important to respect and understand the significance of the title.