Why Kids Prefer Homeschooling to Public Schools

For many families, homeschooling offers a more serene and values-aligned environment for their children compared to public schools. This article delves into the experiences and reasons behind why some children prefer homeschooling and what makes public schools less favorable.

Personal Insights on Homeschooling vs. Public Schools

My journey with the public school system began at an early age. When I was diagnosed with autism at the age of three, my family faced several challenges in the traditional educational setting. The experiences I had were a mix of highs and lows, leading my parents to explore alternative education options, including homeschooling.

The First Grade Adventure

First grade was relatively smooth sailing, until a miscommunication with the gym teacher sent me to the office unexpectedly. It was the exception rather than the rule. However, the experience did trigger some early concerns about classroom dynamics and peer interactions.

The Stresses of Second Grade

Second grade was a period of increased stress due to an inexperienced 24-year-old teacher who was not well prepared to handle a classroom full of diverse learners. I remember the teacher would occasionally give me small assignments or let me take a break, which greatly helped me manage my anxiety. Additionally, speech classes were introduced to address my noticeable lisps with the sounds 'S' and 'TH'.

The Intensification of Third Grade

By third grade, I needed to develop and refine my study skills even more. The learning environment became slightly more intense, but the teacher brought a fun factor that kept us engaged. As the school shifted its focus from rewards-based programs to a more stern approach, the atmosphere changed significantly.

The Turning Point in Fourth Grade

Fourth grade marked a serious transition both academically and behaviorally. I faced a series of challenging incidents, including biting my arm, accidents, and anxiety at home. The environment was stressful, and my behavior reflected that. The teacher became more demanding, and I struggled to maintain focus. Substitutes were brought in during particularly trying moments, leading to even greater disruption.

The Deterioration of the School Environment

As the year progressed, I experienced significant conflicts with peers and staff, especially over issues like Halloween and Harry Potter, which discomforted my parents. I was also upset about homework and church activities. The gym class incident came to a head when I physically reacted to a polytheist student, leading to my first and final detention. This experience significantly impacted my perception of public schools.

The Benefits of Homeschooling

Homeschooling allowed me to thrive in a more supportive and less stressful environment. Here are key benefits:

Reduced Stress and Lowered Anxiety: The structured and controlled environment of homeschooling was crucial in managing my anxiety levels during a particularly challenging period in my education. Focus on Positive Behavioral Development: Homeschooling facilitated a more hands-on and personalized approach to education, which better aligned with my needs and learning style. Maintenance of My Values: Homeschooling allowed me to be taught values that aligned with my family’s beliefs, particularly around Christian and Creationist perspectives, which were not always evident in public schools. Interactive Learning: The ability to engage more deeply and personally with my learning material, like watching The Price Is Right regularly during lunchtime, was a unique and enriching experience.

Challenges of Homeschooling

While homeschooling has its benefits, it also presents unique challenges. One of the biggest issues I encountered was the negative perception of public schools. The environment and behaviors in public schools during my formative years left me with a lasting prejudice, and I often felt that public schools were "evil."

Conclusion

Homeschooling can provide a more nurturing and values-aligned educational experience for children like me who face challenges in traditional public schools. While it has its drawbacks, the benefits of a more relaxed and personalized learning environment cannot be understated. As I approach my 30s, I am beginning to develop a more balanced perspective on public schools and the value they bring to society.

Whether through homeschooling or public schooling, the goal is to provide an enriching and supportive educational experience. Each child's journey is unique, and the best educational option for one may not be the same for another. It is essential to consider the needs and well-being of every student when making these decisions.